Using the estimator
- Enter the insurer’s replacement cost total, before depreciation and deductible.
- Enter your estimate at replacement cost too, so you compare like with like.
- Set a landing point. The slider is your best guess; the three scenario boxes always show 30%, 55% and 80% so you see a range.
- Add fees using your appraiser’s quote and a realistic umpire fee, usually shared equally.
Reading the three scenarios
If appraisal only pays off in the “strong” column, your case depends on everything going right. If the “cautious” column is still comfortably positive, the dispute is more likely worth pursuing. All figures are illustrative and depend entirely on what you enter.
What it doesn’t include
Deductibles, policy limits and the timing of recoverable depreciation change what you are paid but not the size of the dispute. For the payment split, use the depreciation and holdback tracker.
Questions about this tool
Is the projected award a prediction?
No. It’s a planning scenario based on the numbers you enter. Real awards depend on documentation, the panel and the policy.
How much does an umpire cost?
It varies with the size and complexity of the claim. Ask for a written quote once an umpire is proposed; most policies split the fee equally.
